“Dreams” is a story about a person who just will not give up. Once picked on as a kid, Sora, needed help from the captain. She was once too weak to defend herself and with the help of the captain, she was able to stop the bullying. However, Sora still felt weak and puny. She had a drive to be better and strong, so she asked the captain for help. He denied, but gave her a strong piece of advice, “If I could become strong enough to beat him, he would teach me” (Hare 4). As the strong willed hero always does, the challenge began and occurred every day. Upon telling this story to Hikari, Sora never thought any differently. Yet, as the ending showed it didn’t matter because she was never going to give up.
I like the idea behind the story and the use of unconventional character names. By using the different names, it made me pay attention more. I also liked most of your dialogue.
This story is written with a third person narrator. While the dialogue does take up most of the story, I was left wanting more from the main character. I would consider trying it in first person and seeing how the story turns out. It would make some of the dialogue more interesting as well.
The characters in the story are good for the most part. I feel like Hikari needs to have more significance. That character tried to bring forth a revelation, yet fell somewhat short.
This story feels like one giant scene instead of an entire story. This is able to work, but I would be more descriptive in my flashbacks. I would also flesh out the ending a little more.
The story itself needs more description, especially within the main character. Outside of being weak, we really know nothing about them.
I think the structure works and everything is in order
The setting is understood to be a karate club, but I would like more description of the club itself and the battle ground at the end.
The opening sets up the story to make Hikari a more prominent role, yet I feel Hikari came up short in some areas. I do like the character, but it needs to be more descriptive. Also, the character needs to have a more pivotal role.
The closing, for me, needs to be developed more. I think it could be a great ending, but just needs a few things added.